European Urology Publishes Results of SmartTarget Biopsy Trial

The recent issue of European Urology featured the article “The SmartTarget Biopsy Trial: A Prospective, Within-person Randomised, Blinded Trial Comparing the Accuracy of Visual-registration and Magnetic Resonance Imaging/Ultrasound Image-fusion Targeted Biopsies for Prostate Cancer Risk Stratification“, Sami HamidIan A. DonaldsonYipeng Hu, Rachael RodellBarbara VillariniEster Bonmati, Pamela Tranter, Shonit Punwani, Harbir S. Sidhu, Sarah Willis, Jan van der Meulen, David Hawkes, Neil McCartan, Ingrid Potyka, Norman R. Williams, Chris Brew-Graves, Alex Freeman, Caroline M. Moore, Dean BarrattMark EmbertonHashim U. Ahmed.

The study describes the results of medical software developed at UCL that overlays tumour information from MRI scans onto ultrasound images can help guide surgeons conducting biopsies and improve prostate cancer detection.

A team of engineers and medical researchers found that the technology enabled surgeons to pick up clinically relevant cancers that were missed when using current visual detection methods. The best approach would be to use both techniques in tandem, according to the findings published in European Urology.

The software is deployed via a patented system called SmartTarget®.

The advent of MRI-targeted biopsies, where MRI scans are used to inform surgeons where a tumour lies before they conduct a biopsy (tissue sample), has improved detection rates to close to 90% from 50% in the last five years.

Now, the SmartTarget system has further enhanced this technique by allowing a 3D model of the prostate and cancer to be created for each patient from their MRI scans using advanced image processing and machine learning algorithms.

During a biopsy, this model is fused with ultrasound images to highlight the area of concern, which otherwise does not appear in the ultrasound images, helping to guide the surgeon while conducting the procedure.

Until last year when MRI targeting was introduced, the established way to test for prostate cancer involved taking a biopsy from the prostate without knowing where in the prostate a tumour was likely to be, resulting in close to half of life-threatening cancers being missed.

  • Prostate cancer detection has been improving at a very fast rate in recent years, and this technology pushes the science forward even further, enabling clinicians to pick up prostate cancer quickly so that patients can access the right treatment early enough,” – Co-Senior Author Professor Hashim Ahmed, who began the research in UCL Medicine before moving to Imperial College London.

For the present study, 129 people with suspected prostate cancer underwent two biopsies – one using the SmartTarget system, and one where surgeons could only visually review the MRI scans. Funded by the UK Department of Health and Wellcome Health Innovation Challenge Fund, the study was conducted at UCLH.

The two strategies combined detected 93 clinically significant prostate cancers, with each of them picking up 80 of these cancers; each missed 13 that the other method picked up.

The researchers say that surgeons’ visual review of MRI scans should be used in tandem with SmartTarget as using this technique enables surgeons to learn to make subtle adjustments such as adapting to the movement of the patient and the prostate as the needle is inserted.

  • We developed the SmartTarget system to equip surgeons with vital information about the size, shape and location of prostate tumours during a biopsy that is otherwise invisible on ultrasound images,” “The software provides them with a clear target. As MRI-targeted biopsies require a very high degree of expertise and experience, we hope that the imagery displayed by SmartTarget will help to bring high accuracy prostate cancer diagnosis to a much wider range of patients and hospitals.” – Co-Senior Author Dr. Dean Barratt (UCL Medical Physics & Biomedical Engineering and UCL Centre for Medical Image Computing), who invented and led the development of the SmartTarget system.

The researchers say the new methods could reduce the number of biopsies needed, and reduce the unnecessary surgeries caused by over diagnosis of less harmful cancers.

The SmartTarget software has been commercialised by SmartTarget Ltd, a company spun out by UCL’s commercialisation company UCL Business PLC (UCLB), and the system is already in use by several hospitals in the UK and USA.

The inter-disciplinary study brought together engineers, urologists and radiologists, supported by the UCL Translational Research Office in project management and navigating the translational and regulatory pathway involved in taking the project from the lab bench to the operating room.

  • There has been much discussion and speculation in the media recently on the degree to which computers and artificial intelligence will be integrated into clinical care. Studies such as this one are extremely important as they provide valuable evidence on the performance of a new technology in the clinical setting.  With this study we now have hard data showing that SmartTarget is as good as a group of experts in targeting tumours in the prostate, and have a glimpse of how clinicians and computers will be working together in the future for the good of the patient.” – Co-Senior Author Professor Mark Emberton (Dean, UCL Medical Sciences)